
How to Redesign or Move Your Website Without Losing Your Google Rankings
A new website can quietly undo years of search visibility if the move is handled carelessly. This checklist covers what to keep, what to redirect, and what to check in the weeks after launch.
By Jared Saucier October 28, 2026 8 min read
It is a common story. A business launches a better-looking website, and a few weeks later the calls from Google slow down. Nothing is visibly broken. The owner assumes it is the season.
Usually it is the move. Google had learned the old site page by page over years. The new site changed the page addresses, rewrote the text, and dropped a few pages nobody thought mattered. From Google's side, a site it knew was replaced by one it had never seen.
Most of this is avoidable. The steps are not complicated, but they have to happen in the right order, and most of them come before launch. Here is the checklist.
Step 1: Take inventory before anyone designs anything
You can't protect what you haven't listed. Before the redesign starts, build a simple spreadsheet of what exists today.
- List every page address on the current site. Your sitemap (usually at yoursite.com/sitemap.xml) is a good starting point. Include blog posts, old service pages and PDFs.
- Mark which pages bring in visitors. Google Search Console, a free Google tool that shows how your site appears in search, has a Performance report listing the pages and searches that get clicks.
- Save the title and the main heading of each page that gets search traffic.
- Note which pages other websites link to, if you know. Local news stories, supplier directories and chamber listings often point to specific pages.
- Save a full copy of the old site's text and images. Once it is offline, it is hard to get back.
If you don't have Search Console set up yet, do it now, before the move. It needs time to collect data, and you will want a 'before' picture to compare against.
Step 2: Keep your domain
Your domain is your web address, such as yourbusiness.com. It carries the history Google has with your business. Changing it during a redesign means moving two things at once, and that makes any problem harder to diagnose.
Unless you have a strong reason, such as a business name change, keep the same domain. Also confirm that it is registered in your name, with a login you control. If a former web company or employee holds it, sort that out before the project begins. The launch depends on it.
Step 3: Redirect every old page to its new address
This is the step that gets skipped, and it does the most damage. A redirect is a forwarding instruction: when someone asks for the old address, they are sent to the new one automatically. The permanent kind is called a 301 redirect. It tells Google the page has moved for good and the new address should take its place.
Without redirects, every old link leads to a 'page not found' error. That includes links in Google's results, in old Facebook posts, in directory listings and in customers' bookmarks.
- Map every old address to the closest matching new page, one by one, in your spreadsheet.
- Don't send everything to the home page. A person looking for your kitchen remodeling page should land on the new kitchen remodeling page.
- If an old page has no new equivalent, redirect it to the nearest related page, such as the parent service.
- Keep the same address where you can. A page that doesn't move doesn't need a redirect.
- Leave the redirects in place permanently. They are not a temporary launch task.
“Ask your web company for the redirect list before launch. If there isn't one, the move isn't ready.”
Step 4: Keep the titles and content that already rank
A redesign is a tempting moment to rewrite everything. Be careful. If a page already brings in visitors for 'roof repair in Southington,' the words on that page are part of the reason.
For pages that get search traffic today:
- Keep the page title the same or very close. The title is the clickable headline in Google's results.
- Keep the main heading and the core text. Improve the layout, photos and readability around it.
- Don't merge several ranking pages into one short page. Separate service pages usually do better than one long list.
- Don't cut text just to make the design look cleaner. A page with three lines and a large photo gives Google very little to work with.
- Keep image descriptions (called alt text) on photos that had them.
Pages that get no traffic at all are fair game. Rewrite them, combine them or retire them with a redirect. The inventory from Step 1 tells you which is which.
Step 5: Update everything that points at your site
Your website is not the only place your address lives. After launch, check the places outside the site that send people to it.
- Google Business Profile: confirm the website link works. If you link to a booking or services page, check those too.
- Facebook, Instagram and other social profiles
- Directory listings such as Yelp, industry directories and your chamber of commerce
- Any ads you are running. An ad that points to a deleted page wastes every click.
- Email signatures, invoices and QR codes on printed material
- Tracking tools such as Google Analytics, so you can still measure visits and leads on the new site
Redirects will catch most of these. Direct links are still better, and it takes a few minutes to check.
Step 6: Launch-day checks
On the day the new site goes live, go through this list before you announce anything.
- Open several old addresses from your spreadsheet and confirm each lands on the right new page.
- Make sure the site isn't hidden from search engines. Sites under construction are often set to 'do not index,' and that setting sometimes gets left on. Ask your builder to confirm it is off.
- Check that the padlock shows in the browser bar on every page.
- Submit every form and tap every phone button from a phone.
- Submit the new sitemap in Search Console so Google can find the new pages quickly.
- Load the main pages on cellular data to check speed.
Step 7: Watch Search Console for the next few weeks
The job isn't finished at launch. Check Search Console weekly for the first month or two.
- The Pages report lists addresses Google couldn't find. Each 'not found' entry for a real old page is a missing redirect. Add it.
- The Performance report shows clicks and impressions. Compare them with your 'before' picture, page by page.
- If one important page drops while others hold, compare its new title and text with the old version you saved.
Some movement is normal. Google has to revisit every page, and positions can shift for a few weeks even after a careful move. No one can guarantee your rankings will hold, because Google's results are outside anyone's control. What a careful move does is remove the avoidable causes of a drop.
What to ask whoever is building your new site
You don't have to do these steps yourself. You do have to make sure someone does. Ask directly: Will every existing page be redirected? Who writes the redirect list? Will my page titles be kept? Who checks Search Console afterwards? Is any of that an extra charge?
For reference, at Allora Media the $750 Website Build includes moving your existing pages over with redirects, with no page-count limit, and your domain stays registered in your name. Whoever you hire, get the same commitments in writing.
Planning a move? See what is included in our Website Build and how the migration works.
- website migration
- seo
- redirects
- web design
New from the blog, by email
One note when Allora Media publishes something worth reading. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
Questions
More to read
Ready to apply these strategies to your business?
Book a free strategy call. We'll review your current marketing, show you the biggest opportunities, and give you a clear plan, whether you work with us or not.
